Calling the King: Puzzle X5

KR-X5 Puzzle

You are the Declarer in a Call, already holding three Kings and both Skus and XXI. Your hand: Skus, XXI, XVII, XIV, XI, VIII, V, Khearts, Kdiamonds, Kclubs, Qspades, Cdiamonds. The talon halves turn face up. Half A: II, IV, IX. Half B: Qhearts, Jdiamonds, 9spades.

Which half do you take?

Reveal answer

Answer

II, IV, IX. Half B: Qhearts, Jdiamonds, 9spades. Q: Which half do you take? A: Half B, not the Tarok-heavy Half A. Your hand already locks five cards that can never be discarded (the Trull pair and three Kings), leaving only Qspades and Cdiamonds as spare plain filler. Take Half A and you would own ten Taroks and only those same two spares: three discards are owed, but just two are safe, so you would be forced to shed a Tarok in the open AND lose both spares, the Qspades and the Cdiamonds, cards you wanted to keep. Take Half B instead and you add three more plain cards, giving you five safe discards to choose from: send back the weakest plain cards and keep every Tarok and both counting courts intact.