Calling the Twenty: Puzzle E2

CTT-E2 Puzzle

Dodge Round. A trick already holds Qhearts and Chearts (led Hearts). You must follow suit and hold Khearts and 1hearts. The Rising Rule is on: beat the trick if you can.

Which card do you play, and what happens?

Reveal answer

Answer

The Khearts: you have no choice. The Rising Rule forces you to beat the Qhearts if you can, and your Khearts can. Unless the last player is void in Hearts and must trump, you win a trick worth at least 12 Card Points that you desperately did not want. The lesson to carry into bidding: in the Dodge Round, high cards are not power, they are debt. (The 1hearts stays for a trick you can legally lose.)